Thursday, 17 May 2012

Why Arsene would be ‘deluded’ not to sign a keeper

arsene

by JOSH BEDNASH During an ‘It’s Up For Grabs Now’ podcast a number of weeks ago, Alan Davies and the lads came to the conclusion that throughout the course of the season, the goalkeeping infantry at Arsenal had cost us nigh on 12 points. Somewhat inevitably, the retention of these points would have resulted in us winning the league by, yes you guessed it, a single point. In light of this rather hypothetical but nonetheless entirely valid claim, it pains me down to the core that as of yet, we are armed with no more than inane transfer speculation to fight our goalkeeping crisis with. I find it quite staggering that, with the close-season (apologies for the Americanisation) nearly two weeks old, we are still left looking at either Almunia, Fabianski or Mannone with whom to stick between the posts for next season.

 

Presumably Arsene Wenger would have recognised our goalkeeping crisis roughly two months ago, just after Almunia had lost us two points at St. Andrews and quite a while since Fabianski had behaved like anything but a goalkeeper at the Estadio do Dragao. Therefore it leaves me scratching my head that he is yet to sign a goalkeeper. Yes yes I know it’s very early to begin making such rash judgements, but when you way up the other factors which will come into play this summer with regards to any transfer activity, it’s never too early.

Firstly, like any other summer, a new player will need a number of weeks to gel with his teammates, and this is particularly relevant for a number one goalkeeper who will act virtually as a captain and general on the pitch. Secondly, there’s the small matter of the World Cup this summer, which not only separates the team for a month, but will also, as Wenger continues to mention, result in price-tags being raised and money being frittered away, of which Arsene isn’t the greatest fan. And thirdly, it’s not really as if there’s a shortage of potential transfer targets out there at the moment, and frankly, anyone is better than tweedle-Lukasz and tweedle-Manuel.

 

There are a number of possible reasons for this current lack of goalkeeper related transfer activity. One of them, and the one I fear only slightly less than Cesc leaving, is the prospect of Wenger continuing to show faith in Almunia or Fabianksi into next season, of which arguably the latter is more likely. My reason for this is Wenger clearly likes Fabianski, consistently claiming that he will come good, he is a great shot-stopper, or something equally inappropriate. Whether he is as much of a fan of Almunia is debatable, but the way in which he continues to praise Fabianski in his weekly post-match e-mail verges on fandom, immature and potentially satirical fandom for that matter, an example being when he praised Fabianski for being ‘mentally strong’ and responding well during the Man City game, in which he had literally one thing to do.

 

Another possible reason could lie in Wojciech Szczęsny, who Wenger has claimed will ‘certainly be number one’ one day. Whether that day arises in mid-August next season has yet to be seen, although I find this highly unlikely, leading me to believe it will be either Almunia, Fabianksi or ‘Other’ standing in between the posts next season. The prospect of ‘Other’ is far more appealing than the other two options, yet it is far from certain as to who this character will be.

 

The names being thrown around so far have been predominantly Joe Hart, Gigi Buffon and Hugo Lloris, although there have been a few allusions to Robert Green, who for me is one of the most overrated footballers in Europe. Yet the first three candidates would all be brilliant. Joe Hart has had a fantastic season, and hearing him interviewed recently he sounds far too hungry and eager to sit on the bench at Eastlands throughout next season. He therefore seems a viable possibility, convincing me to believe that if Arsene went for it, equipped with around £8m-10 million, we would be sure to get him. As for Buffon, he is still an exceptional goalkeeper, however he is Juventus through and through and even if he did decided to leave would demand extortionate wages.

Although he would probably cost a similar amount to Joe Hart, he is 32 and has a meddling agent who recently expressed that he will not be going to the Premier League. As for Lloris well, he is French, a quality keeper and not too pricey, but unfortunately has recently insisted that ‘a transfer is simply not an option for me right now’, so that puts pay to that then. One wild card may be Shakhtar Donetsk’s Andriy Pyatov, who would cost much less than the other three, but personally I really can’t look beyond David James.

 

Seeing as Arsene Wenger’s over- 40 policy is probably even more stringent than his over-30 policy I really can’t see this one happening but seriously, why not? James is a brilliant keeper- he’s England’s number one for heaven’s sake, and the fact that he has begun applying for managerial positions that he doesn’t have a hope in hell of getting suggests that he hasn’t yet received any appetizing offers from Premiership clubs.

He wouldn’t cost anything, wouldn’t demand ridiculous amounts of money and is a born leader. James never stops shouting at his defenders, even when they’re playing superbly, and he may be just the character we need to solve a plethora of perpetual problems within our squad. Albeit I will admit his arrival is even less likely than Jimmy Bullard replacing Cesc…

 

Nevertheless, whoever Wenger decides to go for, it is fundamental that a new acquisition wears the number one shirt next season because another display of his deluded stubbornness in keeping faith with our current crop would leave him highly culpable for the inevitable failings that would arise.

{jcomments on}

GD Star Rating
loading...

Eldo71

Arsenal fan for 40 years. Schoolboys, North Bank, Clock End then East Upper. Then Emirates. AFC dream team: Wilson, Dixon, Sansom, Adams, Pates, Brady, Williams, Pires, Bergkamp, Henry, Wright. Subs: Seaman, Eldridge, Wilshere, RVP, Ball. Manager: Arsene Chapman.

More Posts - Website - Twitter

  • J@CK

    Can only agree that if Wenger doesn’t address the goalkeeping situation, the season will almost certainly be another disapointment. Arsene is borderline insane if he thinks Almunia and Fabianski are good enough. Also, he does the same thing and expects different results. Both of them aren’t good enough to hold the #1 spot for me. I’d love to see Hart but I doubt we will. I wouldn’t be too suprised if we didn’t see a new ‘keeper but I’d be over the moon if I was to be proved wrong.

    I also read somewhere that Cesc asked Wenger if we were getting a new ‘keeper and Wenger basically said no, which was another major part in Cesc saying he wanted to leave. This was supposedly said in their “meeting” so it could be fictitious.

    Anyway, ‘keeper and a centre-back please Arsene. Keep Cesc aswell though, yeah?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • es

    James?

    Every time I see him play he lets in a shocker.

    I’d rather take my chances with Fabianski.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • nicky

    I wonder whether AW feels that the failings of our back 4 defending set pieces were more to blame than the mistakes of the G/K. He may be inclined to strengthen the 4 and await the January sales if the G/K position doesn’t improve. Is this possible?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • jamesb

    agree, we really need a new keeper almunia is a joke. im worried hes going to give flapyhandski more goes next year to help his confidence this would be ok apart from fact we haven’t won anything in 6yrs and can’t take risks, chesney is suppose to be very good but may be too young and that could be a risk. get keeper who is 30ish have his as number 1 for year or so and then bring in chesney, but for short term at least must get new keeper and CB or we will continue to let in cheap goals

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Not over the hill

    I Believe the Wenger transfer chest is full of IOUs!
    The Citeh money I suspect has already been spent on a Russian and a Belgian.
    The Englishman and the man from Morocco are “freebies”.
    The signs are clear, AW is trying to find money to put on the table as CASH is KING.
    AW is taking the “flak” for a transfer budget which is nearly all IOUs.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • gareth knight

    I dont believe wenger knows how to create a solid defensive unit. I could not believe he started this season with the players we had. Gallas and vermaelen were ok but you knew one would get injured and we had no adequate cover.

    how can you go in to the latter stages of the season with fabianski or almunia between the sticks and silvestre in the centre of defence ? Inexcusable !

    Also we have no cover for alex song, wenger thinks denilson can cover, denilson is not good at defending and not good at attacking.

    I watched in envy last night as inter defended their box, it was a joy to watch even for lovers of the beautiful game.

    Mourinho is on a different level to wenger in so many ways. Wenger is the route of many problems at the club unfortunately.

    You say the goalkeepers cost us them points , I put the blame on arsene for playing them, and add 9 points on top of that in which wenger has had a tactical disaster in substitution decisions and timings.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • george

    you are right he is on a different level .in fact several levels below both as a man and a coach

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • george

    why do halfwits think they know more about football than the best manager in the clubs history?I blame “champ. man.”and the internet that gives a voice to people who in real life would get a smack in the mouth.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • gareth knight

    are you for real, we have 2 sub standard goalkeepers that have made howlers all season. How can any sane person claim that we have 2 great keepers.

    Wenger dropped almunia twice dont forget and talked up fabianski as the next great goalkeeper, what a joke… embarassing !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • John

    Totally agree James would be an excellent piece of buisness he is a solid keeper, a good height, good on crosses and commands the box well i.e gives the defenders a lashing if they are acting the mick.

    U dont have to go out and spend €10M or in some blogs Gigi is going to cost €25M when they is good keeper there for nothing ….okay he is no spring chicken but remember neither are Fredial, Schwarer or Van De Sar.

    Get him Wenger and keep the money to buy a world class centre half.

    Second option would be Hart…. I think alot of people are saying that Gigi and Lloris will be class they have never played in the Preimership with loads of high balls and set pieces playing someone like Blackburn, Boltan etc

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • gareth knight

    Wenger is a great man, the greatest manager our club has seen, he deserves the upmost respect for what he achieved at this club.

    But that does not change the fact that tactically he is not up to par with what should be required for a club that charges the highest amount for tickets anywhere in europe !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Erik

    [quote name=george]why do halfwits think they know more about football than the best manager in the clubs history?I blame “champ. man.”and the internet that gives a voice to people who in real life would get a smack in the mouth.[/quote]
    Completely agree George… “Wenger doesn’t know how to create a solid defence” erm… well he did create a good one that went 49 games unbeaten once and also another one that cost less than £10m total and has the current record for most consecutive clean sheets in the Champions League…

    And even the first defence he had was a success partly down to his revolutionary dieting and training which allowed Adams & co to play for as long as they did.

    Obviously this current defence is victim to the type of football we play, even if we had the best back 4 in the world, they wont keep clean sheets if everyone in front of them is on the attack and someone like Diaby gives the ball away.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Ben

    ok i agree Almunia is not the required standard in terms of consistency…HOWEVER, he has proved for example against Barcalona what a good keeper he is.

    Therefore although i agree we need a new keeper, the abuse and criticism he is getting labeling him as a joke is a bit strong.

    Although admitedly his consistency leaves a lot to be desired, he should be thanked for preventing a completely embarasing scoreline against Barcelona, and sent on his way without the abuse.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • mussyboy

    i think a good defence is first priority, we need to replace gallas,silvestre and campbell.bring in cahill from bolton and hangeland of fulham. then see if keepers need changing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Gooner80

    David James, you must be crazy I would prefer us to get paul robinson because although he makes gaffs like James at least it would wind up the spuds.

    The only person I want to see at arsenal is joe hart, why cant we do a barca and put pressure on city to sell him, they dont need him,Im not no scout but in this world there must be at least one keeper better than ours which are able to be bought at a reasonable price.

    Wenger disregards defence and the goal keeper he doesnt think it is important he thinks he can just outscore the other team. a great goal keeper is worth 15 goals a season, same with defence, sometimes not conceding is worth two goals scored, if wenger cant be bothered with defence at least get in one of the legendary back four to sort them out get seaman as goal keeping coach

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • vito1985

    we also would have won the championsleague in 2006 if it was’nt for manuel the clown almunia! not only is the no.1 keeper important but also the no.2! you never know when you may require the no.2, championsleague final for example! befor coming to arsenal in 2004 almunia was a cast off, unwanted keeper, being loaned out every season to minor spanish clubs. why did we recruit this disaster. dont even get me started on fabianski, im lost for words about the goal keeping problems at arsenal. i have been moaning for years and am shocked it took this long for the media to latch onto it. the fans of clubs need a voice in england! its all about the clubs and the media, and the fans are the puppits that provide the juice for everything to operate, without us there’s nothing. i think its time we realised our worth and done something about it. forza lazio

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • george

    Erik,stop talking sence,you will confuse the halfwits

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Padraic Connell

    okay… just a suggestion… but…
    Craig Gordan? anyone?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • db10

    This is how the transfer market works. Its not just arsenal who operate like this. this has nothing to do with how much we (or any other club) can spend on a player.

    They agree paying off periods over several years for any transfer and if the player leaves for another club then it gets even more complicated. It is not as simple as buying bread and milk because even football clubs like man city don’t have millions IN CASH sitting around in a bank account for immediate payment. They’d be stupid if they did.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • db10

    we can’t afford 2 quality keepers and should be satisfied with 1.

    as for those of you blaming wenger for not signing a keeper last summer or in january I would like to remind you that Almunia was solid and consistent (if not spectacular) last season and the end of the season before that when he replaced mad jens. I, like most fans i think was happy to see him continue at the start of the season.

    As for the january window, there were hardly any transfers and the economic situation outside of the footballing world contributed to this. Also there was and still is very few goalkeepers who were available then and we are finding that there aren’t too many available now.

    Personally I don’t like David James because he’s too old and erratic and I don’t think he should be England no 1 at this world cup. What has happened to the state of English goalkeepers recently? Since seaman there have been a succession of rubbish keepers when historically England has always produced excellent keepers. It seems it’s spains turn to be the goalkeeping Kings (apart from our very own manuel of this season of course).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Oliver

    Yes Arsene will be deluded if keeps the current two goalies. In my view ,with a better goalie,Arsenal could have won at least one to three trophies.For all you know with a top quality goalkeeper,the gunners could have won the cl trophy in 2006.
    These two goalkeepers have been given more than enough chances to be the Arsenal custodian but have failed. If the FM continues to put his faith in them,the gunners will be subject the same consequences.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Mexican Gunner

    Buffon could cost 8-10 m??? I dont think so. Juve will not let him go for less than 25m.

    And Lloris not too pricey? Lyon are rich, Lloris is young, wanted by many big teams and France no. 1. I dont think Lyon let him go for less than 20-25m.

    The most realistic options are: Neuer, Adler, Hart or Stekelenburg.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • GPeace

    Joe Hart has signed for Birmingham City for the whole of next season, so we won’t be seeing him unfortunately. It’s a shame and Wenger missed a trick, just like when he didn’t make a sustained move for Shay Given last year.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Mexican Gunner

    Now imagine that Hart convince Capello in the friendlys and he play a great World Cup and he became the England No. 1 for the next 15 years. Damn.

    Anyway why Birmingham got Foster and Hart?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Pandora beads

    Pandora beads
    Pandora beads wholesale
    Discount pandora beads
    Discount pandora jewelry

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Mexican Gunner

    Damn Merida signed with Atletico de Madrid. :sad:

    Great way to let him go for free after paying 3.2m to Barcelona for formation compensation.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • IndianGunner

    Absolutely right..we dont need james..Only problem with fabianski is the way he handles the crosses..james is even worse than fabianski in handling crosses.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • IndianGunner

    [quote name=gareth knight]
    I watched in envy last night as inter defended their box, it was a joy to watch even for lovers of the beautiful game.
    Mourinho is on a different level to wenger in so many ways. Wenger is the route of many problems at the club unfortunately.

    [/quote]Yes Inter defended well.But they werent playing with 10 men neither bayern played with 12..They started parking the bus from the 1 st minute in the match and was horrible to watch.
    Please dont compare jose with wenger,because jose doesnt manage any clubs for more than 2 years and with the amount of money he gets its not that diffcult to do what he has done.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • IndianGunner

    The main problem in sticking with our goal keepers will be that one mistake from them would be labeled as a crisis and they will be blamed for everything and teams with start attacking in a illegal way similar to black burn match.
    Mark Schwarzer is a very good option..we can get two years out of him and by that time Wojciech Szczesny will be ready for action..we certainly need a new goal keeper.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Mallugooner

    The reason why Arsene Wenger keep on saying that Fabiansky & Almunia are good goal keepers is that he want to sell them on a good rate. If he is saying the y are not good, who will pay at least a satisfactory amount to them and who will want to loan Fabiansky if his manager himself is saying he is not good.

    I am just saying my hunch on this.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Berg10

    Merida is an impatient twat, same as Diarra and Flamini.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Guildford

    Sadly I think that is possible, Wenger is deluded enough not to see that neither keepers are good enough

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Guildford

    Well said

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Guildford

    If we don’t have a decent keeper signed by August,Wenger needs to be sectioned.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • GPeace

    Is it just me or has nobody mentioned Vito Mannone? He looks like a decent prospect and is arguably more prepared than Szczesny to play in the Premier League. I’m convinced Fabianski will still be here next season and, despite everything, still think he could eventuallybecome a top-notch keeper. All I really hope is that Almunia is replaced as soon as possible, he’s 33 but appears no better than our youngsters.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Adm

    Fabregas desperate to win trophies but the question is can Arsenal achieve his ambition in current situation? He had already express his desire to see new players to improve chances of winning silverware. Almunia and Fabianski performances definitely will not give any assurance to him. Gallas can’t accept mistakes, i don’t think Fabregas speak too much with him and at the same i reckon Wenger has some problems to handle him too. Arsenal need a central midfielder too, who can deliver the final ball, quality passing and great scoring abilities. Diaby and Rosicky way too far from Fabregas. Nasri is a good player but struggle to gel in Wenger 4-3-3 formation. Hopefully Wenger will try to do something to change things or we can dream once again next season.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • ProEvoNorthLondon

    Could Jose have replicated Ian Holloways magnificent achievement this season. I doubt it.
    Wenger could have come close although I doubt he would have.
    Take finance out of the matter and AW is no doubt the better football manager. Unfortunately Top level Football is now about extortionate embarrassing amounts of moolah and until the bubble bursts(which it will) Mourinho’s clubs will enjoy more success than Arsenal. No disrespect to Jose though. He is a top top manager. It takes a lot more than a hefty transfer chest to win trophies…ask the fat spanish waiter.
    I wish people didnt automatically equate success with trophies. What AW has achieved with and for Arsenal AND THE PREMIER LEAGUE itself would give me great great pride and a massive feeling of success. The trophies will return and when they do Arsenal will be in a far more dominant position with youth set-up and financial ‘balancing’(???)than their rivals…..Hopefully :-*

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • ProEvoNorthLondon

    “twat”?

    Necessary??

    GD Star Rating
    loading...