Thursday, 24 May 2012

Is Theo Walcott Good Enough For Arsenal?

In 2006, Theo Walcott signed for Arsenal Football Club. The English youngster, who spent the majority of his youth career at Southampton, used his blistering pace to overcome defenders with ease allowing him to gain an impressive reputation in the process.

He first properly introduced himself onto the football scene, when he became the youngest ever Southampton first team player, when he made his Saints debut at just 16 years and 143 days – a record that has not been broken, even with the recent rise of Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain.

Almost 6 years later, Walcott is still very much dependent on his speed. At times, he is unplayable – a term that’s been used by many managers of teams which have been unable to handle him. Even Pep Guardiola suggested that “you would need a pistol to stop him”.

Despite receiving such overwhelming comments, especially from a man who works so closely with Messi, Villa, Xavi and Iniesta – and the rest – Arsenal fans have become frustrated with the young winger.

Walcott was called up to the England squad for the 2006 World Cup at just 17 years of age, despite not even kicking a ball for the Arsenal first team. A hugely impressive, yet highly controversial move, which still to this day earns Sven-Göran Eriksson criticism – amongst many other things!

I often pity Theo, as before he was even able to prove himself, he was thrown immediately into the deep end. For a proportion of football fans, his move to Arsenal suggested that the young winger was destined to become a world-class footballer for both country and club. But after an on and off career in North London, that apparent guarantee seems to have halted.

Since his arrival at Highbury six years ago, he’s had moments where he has totally stunned the crowd, usually with his speed being the vital factor in his success. However, his main problem is that his level of consistency is not good enough. His history on the treatment table deserves a mention too.

He has the potential to become a great player for both Arsenal and England. But for me, the problem boils down to the seemingly-obvious fact that he lacks a footballing brain. Admittedly, I sometimes question how he even made it as a professional footballer – until I see him running, of course! His shooting skills can be refreshingly impressive at times, but generally, his finishing in front of goal is predictably disappointing.

I’m no Arsene Wenger – obviously. But I do have a suggestion that could help Walcott out. When we are defending a corner, why do we get everyone back?

Players like Walcott and Arshavin are not needed inside the box. I’ll always stress that these players need to stand further up the field, ready to become part of a quick breakaway. Not only could it lead to a possibility of a fast counter attack, but it would also force the opposition to bring players back, giving our defenders a more comfortable advantage to prevent the aerial threat.

This piece isn’t a dig at Theo Walcott. Like I’ve said, I believe he has the potential to become a great Arsenal player. I really hope he proves me wrong and achieves great things at the club. But I’ll be honest, week after week, my frustration is growing. Of course, I want him to succeed and do the best he possibly can for the club, but his performances aren’t exactly filling me with confidence.

So, is he good enough to play for The Arsenal? At the moment, I’m tempted to say that he isn’t. But with Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain knocking on the door, it seems that I’ll have a more concrete answer sooner rather than later.

 

by MIKE HARVEY | Follow me on Twitter @my_karvey

GD Star Rating
loading...

I'm 20 and have been an Arsenal season ticket holder since 2006. My family has had Arsenal links since the 1920's, and the support is still going strong. I am at every home game, and also manage to get to multiple away games, when I can.

I have been writing for various blogs and websites since I was 15, but have now settled down and have become a regular writer for Arsenalinsider. I also run my own Pro Evolution Soccer blog, Only Pro Evolutions.

Arsenal is my passion. Writing is my passion. I was never good enough to play for The Arsenal, so I'll do the next best thing!

  • Tom

    Good article – to answer the question in the title, I would say yes. As depressing as it is to admit, this Arsenal team are nowhere near as good as Arsenal teams of old. Theo is unbelievably inconsistent, but his numbers this season in terms of goals and assists are actually quite impressive considering how poor the team has been in general.

    Whenever I think to criticise Theo, I do remind myself that without him we probably wouldn’t be in the Champions League, so let’s cut him a little bit of slack – there are far more disappointing players in the squad at the moment.

    And finally, it was Sven that called him up for the World Cup, not Capello. :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • trugooner21

    I have been asking myself this question since last season. I still think he is suited to the super sub role. he has proven to be effective as a sub but for a starting 11 man he is too inconsistent. he seems to only be good for a few bursts of speed throughout a game and once he is a little tired he is no use any more. One on one he lacks ability and when playing against a team that has fast defenders he seems to disappear from the game. Good player?…yes. Starting 11?…no!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Defo

    Yes

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • NickA

      Laconically put Defo.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  • Bigsyisback

    Played down the middle of course he is, but out wide is total and utter nonsense, the kid cannot cross a ball with accuracy consistently enough and the better the opposition the less time and opportunity for a delivery, so each time it occurs it has to be accurate and he is just not good enough at it.
    This is not just a Walcott issue in the English game, Lennon, SWP, are crap at it too..

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      couldn’t play up top in a 4-5-1 that we play. He can’t keep the ball on the right wing when he’s up against a full back and sometimes a midfielder tracking back. How does anyone expect him to be able to keep it when he’s up against 2 centre backs and sometimes a defensive mid as well. Would only work in a 4-4-2 where he can play on the shoulder. But i don’t think he’s good enough that we should change formation just to suit his style of play. If he can’t adapt then he isn’t good enough.

      However there are plenty of other reasons why it would probably be better for us to play 4-4-2 but that’s another matter.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Bigsyisback

        Yep..a fair comment put like that.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  • carmelo pace

    SHORT AND SOUR TO THEO,NO YOU ARE NOT GOOD ENOUGH

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • James-c-anderson

    If your not going to play theo dwn the middle then dont play him at all

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Anonymous

    You can only play him down the middle in a 4-4-2 because he isn’t good enough to play up top on his own. So considering we haven’t played that formation for years and he isn’t suited to any other formation I would say no.

    Honestly, this season he has been lazier than Arshavin as well. Especially when it comes to making forward runs. Arshavin doesn’t bother defending  but it is really worrying when a forward can’t be arsed even to jog 30 yards into the box to support the other attacking players.

    The number of times rvp and gervinho are around the box and theo is standing around on the right about 40 to 50 yards out is ridiculous.

    However, saying all that, under a different manager who is able to motivate his players better, and if he had someone to learn from in the squad, he has the potential to be a much better striker than the average (generous?) winger he is now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Cophy

    very true about wen defendin a corner. i always say he shudnt b in the box at all. typical example is the champions league game against liverpool at anfiled wher toure told him 2 prepare 2 run lol. he broke away wit the ball and provided the assist 4 adebayor. typical arsenal move that we dont see anymore

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Carson

    Theo
    guaranteed Arsenal’s qualification for the Champions League this year
    against Udinese and the goal he scored away is the type of goal he
    should be scoring regularly; a simple one two past the opposition
    fullback or a lob over the top for him to run onto. Until the
    midfielders start utilising Theo’s pace and put him through he’ll
    continue to frustrate. Theo should be the attacking outlet when
    Arsenal are pinned back in their own half, and as much as I hate to
    say it, a well placed long-ball would be most effective.

    He’s
    a decent finisher and as much as we’d like to see him tear it up all
    the time, he won’t; but that’s not say he can’t be a great player for
    the club. Barring injury, Theo will probably score from 13-16 goals
    this year, hopefully more. That’s not a bad contribution from a
    player by any means. He also has a knack of getting goals in big
    games. I’d like it if he drifted infield more to show that he can
    play in the middle as a Michael Owen (before he went to Madrid) type
    player.

    Theo
    is good enough; he’s just not Thierry Henry, the player we all wanted
    him to be. But Henry was older than Theo when he made the switch to
    the middle and Theo has time on his side, though some Arsenal fans
    would have you believe otherwise. He’ll be one of the players that
    lifts Arsenal out of its slump and the crowd will start up the “Theo”
    chants again. Can’t wait!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Carson

    That weird formatting aint’ my fault! haha

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Tesodi

    Theo is best played in the middle, not wings.  Wenger has not helped him, just like nasri and ashavin being pushed to the wings and became less effective.   Fault with wenger.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Bradley Stuart

      I see Wenger making many mistakes before but I agree that he does not seem ready to play as a striker. I believe playing him on the wing has not helped him become a striker.
      When he arrived he needed to be loaned out to learn his trade but the hype forced Wenger’s hand to play him as England’s next super star. Due to his pace he was put on the wing and used it to beat players, where if he struggled, he would’ve had to learn skills too and Wenger could’ve said he wasn’t ready yet and loaned him out. I think wenger learned from his mistake with Walcott with regards to the other youngsters.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  • Alex

    Theo is statistically good, albeit inconsistent. People forget that he is still young and has alot to learn. His pace and finishing are an incredible asset to Arsenal, and he is versatle since he can play on either wing or in the centre. He’s definately good enough to stay in the starting XI (as long as he becomes more consistent) but in my opinion he is better as a ‘super-sub’ since his pace is even more devastating against weary opponents.

    In my opinion, if Arsenal bring in someone like Hazard, Walcott will become an even better player because he will be forced to lift his game in order to challenge for the starting XI. Although i like Arshavin’s creativity, I can imagine Theo displacing him as the ‘go-to’ forward/winger when the chips are down.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Peta

    I do think he’s good enough but as you said he was just thrown in at the deep end. He’s now just been given the opportunity to prove himself he will get there regardless let’s give him a chance.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Godfather_cwq

    I think it’s a mistake writing an article like this. We’ve lost enough talent, so this is a discouraging read for him. Sure he’s a frustration at times but so are most of them. Sure we want answers so we look at who to blame. Trouble is it’s hard not to look at the past andcompare. Theo and others aren’t fortunate enough like other lesser Arsenal players were when they played with “World Class” players who made them look good and improved their game. Don’t blame Theo. He’s just part of a poor team that has not settled for at least 5 years. Theo would have shone in “The Invincibles” squad, but he’s not a leader in a team lacking much leadership. Theo is as good as his environment. He never created this environment. As for O/C. I hope he is a spark to ignite us, but hang on a mo. Give him a chance to do his laces up. Who knows him and Theo may not have to clash but form a great partnership.

    Who knows? I know this though. No one stays where they are not wanted. This isn’t 1991 and we don’t have a billionaire. Welcome to the present. Sucks doesn’t it. This is the environment of big business without regulation. Last week Plymouth Argyle had a crowd of 8000. They are rock bottom of all the leagues because of bad investments. The players weren’t even getting paid. The environment is created because there isn’t an even playing field. Otherwise the greedy players whose names we sing along to on the terraces would stay for love. Not leave for silly money!

    Gentlemen. Theo is a really good player. Let’s not encourage our wadded rivals to steal him away. We are stuck with a club that tries to have principles and is suffering because of them. We are stuck with Sky who glorifies the top flight with no care for the history of our fellow clubs. We are stuck with an FA that won’t champion regulating investment, wages or to ensure a number of squad members are from the locality of the club.

    Create a level playing field, then we can sat down an discuss Theo, amongst others. Personally, I see him as one of the family. I don’t want to let HIM down!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Bradguns

    @ Tesodi arshavin played as a rw b4 arsenal nasri played as rw and lw at Marseilletheo was a winger at southhampton and quite frankly cant hold up the ball at all so i dont see how he can play right through the middle 

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • John in Norfolk

    Who are you going to pick on next Mike Harvey?  I don’t recall you having anything good to say about anything at Arsenal.  Your kind of negative posting is indicative of the instant gratification so yearned for by people of your generation.  Twenty years old and think you know all about football.

    Another post and forget blogger.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • http://twitter.com/My_Karvey Mike Harvey

      It’s much more interesting to write something with a potentially controversial opinion in mind. Maybe you could name me a writer who has got far, by glorifying every single player of every single team?

      PS: Thanks for the support.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Fasad

        So you admit your are just a hack in it for the views?

        If you are having thinking of journalists who eschew sensationalism for integrity, well, there really isn’t more to discuss, is there.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  • normski

    5 years ago he was a boy who needed regular first team football and he didnt get it, the reason why he appears not to have a footballing brain is because he had very little first team experience at a crucial time of his development.  could have been one of the greatest.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Yalam

    He has a long way to go. Each coach demands different things from him & i question whether this has made him unstable. He is fast with ball but his final decision making is horrible especially when he plays @ wings.However, i don’t see him as a typical CF but he is good when he plays behind VP. His movement is good. Remember the 2008 game against Man U where he made a diagonal run to pull Vidic & create space for Nasri for the second goal!! I want to see more of this from him as VP is not as mobile as Walcott. However, he has to be able to adapt. Playing as winger shouldn’t restrict him from making those cuts or coming inside. Look at what Pires & Ljunberg did. 
    His finishing has certainly improved compared to previous years though. 

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Pingback: Theo Walcott - the secret to his recent success for Arsenal