Arsenal News
FTK Blog: As Walcott fails should Wenger now leave?
The news story that must be very infuriating for Gooners at the moment is the failure of Theo Walcott to make the final 23 England World Cup squad to South Africa. The public criticism of Theo during a training session is being held up as one of the reasons for the U-turn by Fabio Capello. The consequences may help or hinder the lad’s progress. Theo Walcott has been held back by recurrent injuries and added to the lack of team selection by Arsene Wenger, he has failed to really demonstrate his true potential other than as an impact player off the bench. Having previously been a great fan of the player, I have to be honest that his performances have been less than convincing. He cannot go around players with confidence and has no “tricks” to speak of. To suggest that he is worse than Sean Wright-Phillips and Aaron Lennon is not exactly an insult, but amounts more to a clear indication that his skills need close coaching attention. I would disagree with those who say that Theo is over rated and just an athlete in football boots.
Â
One has to ask why some players make it under Arsene Wenger and others do not. I am a supporter of Arsene Wenger, but some of his statements leave me very frustrated. I detect that the man is one of deep conviction, and those convictions appear to me to have a political foundation. In fact so political that Arsene himself has become a prisoner of his own philosophies. I perceive that his goal is to create an egalitarian camaraderie within the squad. This has I believe manifested itself in the contradiction where whilst playing for England, Theo Walcott is encouraged to be selfish in front of goal and take goal scoring opportunities as opposed to Wenger’s favoured pass the ball to a colleague. One of the biggest criticisms of this Arsenal squad is their almost phobic fear of shooting anywhere outside of the 18 yard box. Even Arshavin used to be a prolific shooter from long range before he came to Arsenal, I cannot recall the last time that he used those skills last season.
Â
Even in the pay policy at Arsenal we can see political undertones, where ordinary players are prevented from feeling stigmatised by receiving an inflated salary so that the gap between the highest paid player and the lowest is not great. Paying such young players high salaries prevents them being moved on before the end of a contract as no club outside of the Premier League can afford to pay the salaries, so the ridiculous situation occurs with the Club still paying the salaries whilst the player is out on loan. I disagree with this policy, preferring a compromise between the prima donna mega salary and the salary that rewards high skills and consistent performance befitting a star player. This pay policy has in my view created a lethargy, a laziness and comfort zone from within which there is no desire to fight for the club.
Â
Where else is the political doctrine that is Wengerism obvious? The coaching drills that require a stop watch and a ball are all too predictable. What our players need is the ability to develop football strategy without the ball, the art of positioning, the timing of runs and most importantly what can only be described as defensive awareness. Too often we hear players stating that Wenger doesn’t talk to players individually other than to say, “you know what you must do” almost expecting a telepathic ability and DIY approach to skills improvement. Perhaps Arsene Wenger’s skills one to one are not as good as we think that they are. All of the mega Arsenal stars of recent memory have already been very talented players before coming to Arsenal. I am tempted to suggest that I have not seen a “bad” Arsenal player in terms of skill set, improve under Arsene’s guidance.
Â
So here in lies the conundrum, what if Arsene Wenger’s main skills are only strategic and he lacks the precious one on one inspiration which can create world class prospects from good players. What if Wengerism itself is just a myth, and over the seasons all that we have seen is “team Wengerball” and individual genius from our gifted minority? What if Theo’s lack of progress is due to confusion in the players mind as to how he should develop? It is that sense that I would describe his lack of progress being down to having fallen victim of this team culture. Arsene Wenger’s skills in football economics and business studies are clear for all to see. His vision of attacking team culture through Wengerball has revolutionised the style of football, but without the genius that say the likes of Dennis Bergkamp and Thierry Henry brought to the party, perhaps then we were all deceived.
Â
With the breaking news that Barcelona have confirmed the beginning of formal negotiations to sign our world star Cesc Fabregas, Could it be that Arsenal are about to lose yet another player with genius? I am extremely shocked that the Club are now negotiating away our chief asset after apparently having told the Catalans that he is not for sale. Coaching the remaining squad now becomes more important than ever before. This is where the likes of Pat Rice and the assembled coaching staff have to take the blame for our current malaise. I wonder if they ever actually tell Arsene Wenger that sometimes, we need individuals in a team to create inspiration. There appears to be nothing done until Arsene Wenger says that it must be done, this include tactics on the field, the timing of substitutions etc. So what is the solution? I wish to propose a radical evolution rather than revolution. Surely it is now time for Arsene Wenger to leave the frontline coaching role at Arsenal, and become our director of football? He has run the club from top down, and he cannot have enough hours in the day to give personal attention to those players in greatest need. My suggestion is for someone like Dennis Bergkamp to come in and lead the coaching staff and become manager and effectively Arsene’s number two. Effectively freeing up Arsene to concentrate upon his strategic vision for the club. In so doing we can protect the legacy of Arsene Wenger who is and will remain the greatest manager in our club history. Surely that is something worth cherishing?
Â
FTK.
|
Next Match
Arsenal v Bolton Premier League Sat, September 11 Time: 15:00 On: ATVO |
Last Match |
|
|
Comments
Are you so naive as to believe everything written in the blogs and tabloids? Just b'se Barca says something, it must be true! What a plonker!
Have you seen the statement on the Arsenal FC website, or were you burning to have a go at Wenger and couldn't wait a second for the whole truth to filter through?
People like you make my blood boil!
Also this team is built around Cesc and if he leaves it won't just be a case of buying someone who will fill in for him. The way we play will have to change around a new group of players and with Wenger not getting any younger and with the recent failure to bring trophies perrhaps he is not the best person to build a new team because lets be honest, this team is the leftovers of the team he wanted to have. Flamini, Hleb, Adebayor, kolo were all supposed to be in the current team.
Maybe if Cesc leaves its time for a change of tact and we will need to rebuild again and a change of manager could be the best way to rebuild the team and freshen things up. And if Cesc stays then great and Arsene should stay. Funny how things have turned around.
"To be clear, we will not make any kind of counterproposal or enter into any discussion. Barcelona have publicly stated that they will respect our position and we expect that they will keep their word."
We don't need supporters like you at the Arsenal.
Arsene Wenger can not be blamed for some players developing and others not, no player is a robot some develop differently or take in whats being taught to them differently. Arsene can not control Theo's brain he can only give him the tools to improve, it is down to Theo to use them.
To sum this up really, your just an utter idiot with a terrible article. Next time analyse your statements
On the one hand you castigate Wenger for being prepared to negotiate "away our chief asset after apparently having told the Catalans that he is not for sale", which is patently wrong, but you could wait for truth. On the other hand, you accuse the same Wenger of an inability to cauch Theo well enough that Capello couldn't leave him behind!
Do you see the holes in your argument? Even if we entertain for a moment that Wenger would sell Fabregas, which remains untrue/unproven, who brought the celebrated Fabregas from under the noses of Barca for a pittance? Is it not the same Wenger you're castigating? And were he to sell Fabregas back to Barca at tens of millions, who exactly is the fool and who is the genius? Obviously, not you!
"yesterday evening we received an offer from Barcelona for Cesc and in response, we immediately and resolutely told them once again that we have no intention of selling our captain.
"To be clear, we will not make any kind of counterproposal or enter into any discussion. Barcelona have publicly stated that they will respect our position and we expect that they will keep their word."
Second of all Dennis Bergkamp does not like to fly. How will he coach the team during the champions league?
And third, If Wenger is not good at nurturing talent then why do so many players pay tribute to his talents as a coach and owe their careers to him?
and for ur information...we scored most goals from outside the box last season.
Why do you think he (Fabregas) was so keen to publicly emphasize how much he respected Wenger, and how much that conversation meant to him, "probably the greatest conversation I've heard with anyone", and that would include his own dad!
He said all that despite back constantly and unashamedly prodding him to disassociate himself from Arsenal and Wenger by making some public declaration, or even submitting a transfer request, which he never did!
Now, don't get me wrong, I adore the way the lad plays for us, the passion he shows and all that, and would support him fully if he stayed. But, don't let your small mind get confused! The glue that holds the whole of Arsenal FC together, the genius that stole "your greatest asset" from under the noses of Barca, and would sell him back only for mountains of money, is Wenger, the one you so shortsightedly and illogically castigate!!
As to Theo....just because AW has failed (so far) with Theo means he doesn't develop world class players? Who the hell has made Cesc since the age of 16 into one of the world's finest attacking midfielders? Who turned Henry from a little known winger into a world class striker? Who turned local boy ACole into one of the world's finest leftbacks?
So he may fail with Theo...you think Fergie's succeeded with every young player he's every brought in?
Can't blame AW for that.
Erm yes one does - cos this never happens at ANY other clubs..?
Aside from that, who are you talk about failure and write him off at 21? Cashley didn't even make the first team until 23 - Walcott just needs some time. He has already proven himself a useful and dangerous impact substitute.
Yes he is frustratingly inconsistent but remains hugely promising.
But no you're right - the manager should definitely go for this.
I'm not saying there isn't some middle ground but you really seem to have lost your belief.
And I would also agree about the coaching staff especially when it comes to "playing the opposition" (instead of only concentrating on our own game) which is necessary at times. It seems obvious against barca and chelsea and man u this season that we didn't try to stop them from playing but tried to play our own game and it turned out that we weren't as good at our game as they were at their game. That is the only way small teams beat bigger teams.
Also I think we need a proper defensive coach - full time. Its surprising that Wenger was a centre back but doesn't seem to be very good at (or maybe is not interested in) defensive coaching.
And I don't think we can blame Wenger for Theo's lack of improvement. Look at Song for example who had much less "natural" advantages than Theo and has gone from being nowhere near the starting 11 to one of the first names on the team sheet. Even Diaby and Denilson have improved in the last year or 2 (although they did start from a pretty low level!) and I don't know why Theo hasn't but its down to him to improve his performances. A good manager only rarely makes average players look good.
And we do have an attitude of 'We will outplay you regardless of who you are'. And we have come up short this year against Chelsea, Mancs and Barca.
Ouch.
I am a great believer in the blaugrana and try to avoid the azulgrana. Scarlet and blue colours of "more than a Team". Blau is Caatalonian for blue, need I go on?
Pep Guardiola apparently wants a front line of Robbens, Messi and Villa! If not Robbens, then Mata (also Valencia at present), Messi and Villa! BUT if Silva goes, Juan Mata stays or vice versa!
Jaime Ferrer by the way is a "dolphin", otherwise poodle in English, for Joan Laporta. Does Guardiola call the tune? Laporta is setting his stall out for the next time! Cesc salary will be ÂŁ125,000 per week!
Myles Palmer (Arsenal news review)
Sinbad (Arsenal Action)
The famous troll among Arsenal supporters.. from the looks of thing, you're joining them
Get a decent writer
Is this a FTK post or a Maximus post? No matter, I can feel the desire building now; it may have taken a while, but you are getting there.
Good post, by the way. Damn good post!
As I've said all along, let's be gone with him. He has served his purpose. Do it now, whilst he has a skerrick of credibility intact.
This blog was actually written from the heart with much pain. Not a knee jerk, and at the time of writing the official news from Barca had yet to have an official response from the Club. I cannot be blamed for reacting to official statements from Barca on their websites, call them liars not me!
But back to the deeper message of this blog. I have not turned against Arsene Wenger, the last sentence should indicate the depth of admiration that I have for him and my desire to see his legacy preserved.
Whether we like the reality or not, Arsenal Football Club is very divided, it has been in the past, but there are aspects of this current division which is self inflicted, and yes, Arsene Wenger is responsible for that.
His coaching staff and number two appear not to be able to influence matters and is it so heretical to call for changes?
As for the development of Theo, he is young and very talented yet there are persistent aspects of his game that need addressing on the practice ground and I have seen precious little improvement over this season, injuries aside who is responsible for this?
We have the third or fourth biggest wage bill but how many players are in the 20-30million brac ket like those of ManU?
I am convinced that Walcott the player will succeed,and his failure to make the final 23 could make or break him. Hopefully he will rise from the ashes with determination.
But to say that all is well at Arsenal and not to try and analyse the likely cause and solution is navel gazing of the highest extent and I refuse to do it even though it makes me unpopular.A blog is a collection of observations and a public airing of thoughts. I am not the oracle or a football manager, just an ordinary fan like you all searching for a solution.
FTK.
RSS feed for comments to this post